Forum

Faster Pictures, Same Law: Nano Banana 2 and the End of the Thaler Case

Points of blue light spraying from a fiber optic lamp against a dark background

Two events in the last week of February and the first days of March describe the state of AI imagery with unusual clarity.

On 26 February, Google introduced Nano Banana 2, built on Gemini 3.1 Flash, and described it as its best image generation and editing model. The pitch is quality close to its Pro model at the speed and price of its Flash line, and Nano Banana 2 becomes the default image model in the Gemini app. Image generation, already fast, is getting faster and cheaper again.

On 2 March, the US Supreme Court declined to hear Thaler v. Perlmutter. Stephen Thaler had asked the Court to overturn decisions holding that a picture created autonomously by his AI system, the Creativity Machine, could not be registered for copyright because it had no human author. With certiorari denied, the appeals court ruling stands: under US law, copyright requires a human author.

More images, made more easily, under an authorship rule that has not moved. That combination will shape creative work for years.

The end of a test case

Thaler was always an extreme case by design. Thaler did not claim to have shaped the image; he listed the machine as the sole author. That made it a clean test of whether US copyright law could recognize a non-human author, and every level of review said no.

It also means the case leaves the harder questions open. Most people using AI do not claim that the machine is the author. They claim that they are, because of their prompts, choices and edits. Those claims are being tested elsewhere. In January, in a separate case brought by artist Jason Allen, the Copyright Office told a federal court in Colorado that entering prompts at least 624 times did not make him the author of the image Midjourney produced, because the system, not the person, determined the expressive result.

Between those positions, a working rule is emerging. Human control over expression matters. Volume of instructions does not substitute for it.

Why cheaper images raise the stakes

As image models improve, the amount of purely generated material in the world grows faster than anyone can review it. Much of that material will not be protected by copyright at all, which has consequences for anyone who builds a business on it.

  • A brand that relies on purely generated visuals may find it hard to stop competitors from copying them.
  • A studio that delivers generated assets to clients may be delivering material that no one can own outright.
  • An artist whose distinctive contribution is human selection, arrangement or modification needs evidence of that contribution if it is ever challenged.

Speed, in other words, changes the economics of making images. It does not change the legal value of the result.

Where the human work lives

For designers, the practical question is where their authorship sits in a workflow built around fast models. The answer is usually in three places: the material they bring in, such as their own drawings, photographs or 3D work; the selection and arrangement of outputs into a composition; and the modifications they make by hand afterward. All three can be documented, and all three can be strengthened deliberately.

A reminder for entrants

Competitions that recognize AI-assisted work increasingly ask the same questions courts do. The International AI Award asks entrants to explain how they used AI, which models and versions they chose and why, and what innovations they brought to the process. Answers that show human decisions at each stage are more persuasive to a jury, and more defensible in any later dispute, than a list of prompts.

The takeaway

The Supreme Court did not settle how much human involvement is enough. It confirmed that some is required. As tools like Nano Banana 2 make images ever easier to produce, the value of a creative professional will lie less in producing pictures and more in the authored decisions that turn pictures into work. Those decisions deserve to be made carefully and recorded clearly.