Forum
Permission at the Edge: Getty Narrows Its Case as Cloudflare Flips the Default

Two pieces of news from the past fortnight, one from a courtroom and one from an infrastructure company, point the same way. The most practical place to control how creative work is used for AI may be the moment it is collected, not years later in court.
What happened in London
On 25 June, as closing arguments began in Getty Images’ case against Stability AI at the High Court, Getty dropped its primary copyright claim over the training of Stable Diffusion. Reporting on the decision pointed to the evidential and jurisdictional problem at its heart: Stability is based in London, but the training was carried out on computers outside the United Kingdom. Proving that infringing copying happened in the UK was always going to be difficult.
The case continues on narrower ground, including secondary infringement, which turns on whether a trained model can count as an infringing copy brought into the country, as well as trademark and passing-off claims linked to Getty’s watermarks. A judgment will follow later. But the retreat on the central claim is already instructive.
Copyright law is territorial. Training is not. A model can be trained in one country, hosted in another and used everywhere. A rights holder who wants to challenge the act of training has to find a court with jurisdiction over the place where it happened, and evidence of what happened there.
What happened on the network
On 1 July, Cloudflare, which sits in front of a large share of the world’s websites, announced that it would block AI crawlers by default. New domains signing up are asked whether to allow AI crawlers, with blocking as the default, reversing the usual pattern in which publishers had to opt out. The company also launched a private beta of Pay Per Crawl, letting site owners set a price for access, and said it would ask AI crawlers to declare whether they collect content for training, for answering queries or for search.
Whatever its commercial motives, the move changes where permission lives. Instead of a legal argument after the fact, it is a technical decision at the point of collection.
Why this matters for visual creators
For illustrators, photographers and designers, the lesson of both stories is that hosting choices are now rights choices.
- Your portfolio’s infrastructure matters. Whether your site sits behind a provider that blocks or charges AI crawlers affects how your work is collected.
- Signals create a record. Robots rules and crawler settings are not perfect protection, but they document what you permitted and when.
- Agencies and platforms make decisions on your behalf. If your images are licensed through a stock agency or hosted on a social platform, its policies may matter more than your own settings.
- Jurisdiction is not abstract. Where a model is trained, and where you could enforce a claim, can decide whether a claim is worth bringing at all.
Limits worth remembering
Default blocking does not undo collection that has already happened, and not every crawler identifies itself honestly. Large datasets assembled in earlier years remain in circulation. Courts will still be needed for disputes that infrastructure cannot settle.
Nor is blocking always the right answer. Some creators want their work to be discoverable in AI-powered search, or are willing to license it on fair terms. The point of a default is not to forbid; it is to make permission a choice rather than an assumption.
The award angle
Competitions sit on the other side of this exchange. They collect work, publish it and promote it. The rules of the International AI Award state that submitted images are used to promote the award with credit given, and that entrants must own the work or have permission to submit it. Clear terms like these are the competition-sized version of the same principle: say in advance how work will be used, so nobody has to argue about it later.
The direction of travel
The Getty case will produce a judgment, and other cases elsewhere will produce more. But the past fortnight suggests that the practical balance of power is shifting toward whoever controls the doorway. For creators, that means paying as much attention to where their work is published as to what the law says about it afterwards.



